Navigating California's Commercial Insurance Market

December 11, 2025

Navigating California’s Commercial Insurance Market

California business owners are currently facing a demanding insurance landscape. Securing comprehensive and affordable commercial auto and property insurance has become increasingly complex. A combination of factors, including economic pressures, severe weather events, and a challenging legal environment, is contributing to rising premiums and stricter coverage terms.

At Teague Insurance, we believe that informed clients are empowered clients. Our commitment is to provide you with the clarity and support needed to navigate these conditions effectively. This article will explore the key challenges in California’s commercial insurance market, offer actionable strategies for your business, and provide an outlook on what to expect in the future.

Key Challenges in California’s Commercial Insurance Market

Understanding the forces shaping the current insurance environment is the first step toward managing your risk. Several distinct pressures are impacting both commercial property and auto insurance lines across the state.

Commercial Property: A Market Under Pressure

California’s unique geography and climate present significant risks for property owners, which are intensified by economic and regulatory factors.

Increased Catastrophic Events: The frequency and severity of natural disasters are major drivers of rising insurance costs. Wildfires, in particular, have caused billions of dollars in damage, leading insurers to re-evaluate their risk exposure. For example, the Eaton and Palisades Fires in early 2025 damaged over 15,000 structures. This has made it difficult for businesses in high-risk areas to find affordable coverage, with some carriers exiting these markets entirely.
Regulatory Environment: California’s regulatory framework, including Proposition 103, governs how insurers can set rates. While intended to protect consumers, these regulations can slow down the process for insurers to adjust to rising risks. As a result, some carriers have reduced their presence in the state, limiting availability and competition.
Rising Repair and Rebuilding Costs: Inflation and supply chain disruptions have significantly increased the cost of construction materials and labor. This means that in the event of a loss, the expense to repair or rebuild a property is much higher, which directly translates to higher insurance premiums.

Commercial Auto: Navigating the Road Ahead

The commercial auto sector faces its own set of significant challenges, leading to sustained rate increases for businesses that rely on vehicle fleets.

Driver Shortages and Inexperience: The transportation industry is grappling with a persistent shortage of qualified drivers. To fill vacancies, some companies may lower their hiring standards, leading to a workforce with less experience. This trend is often associated with a higher frequency of accidents and claims.
Increased Claims Severity: The cost per claim is rising due to several factors. Advanced vehicle technology, such as driver-assistance systems, makes repairs more complex and expensive. Furthermore, medical costs associated with accidents continue to climb.
Social Inflation and “Nuclear” Verdicts: A rise in large jury awards for accident-related lawsuits, known as “nuclear verdicts,” has dramatically increased the financial risk for insurers. This trend has contributed to a surge in claim costs over the past decade, forcing carriers to raise premiums to cover potential losses.
Distracted Driving: The continued prevalence of distracted driving remains a primary cause of accidents, contributing to higher claims frequency and pushing insurance rates upward for all commercial policyholders.

Strategies for California Business Owners

While the market presents challenges, proactive risk management can help you secure the best possible coverage and control costs. Our team is dedicated to helping you implement these strategies effectively.

Prioritize a Strong Safety Culture: For commercial auto, implementing a robust fleet safety program is essential. This should include regular driver training, comprehensive onboarding for new hires, and the use of telematics to monitor driving behavior and identify areas for improvement.
Thoroughly Review Your Policy: It is critical to understand the specifics of your coverage. Pay close attention to endorsements and exclusions, especially in surplus lines policies. Look for sublimits on certain types of damage, such as water, and understand whether your policy provides for replacement cost or actual cash value.
Maintain Your Property: For property owners, proactive maintenance can significantly reduce your risk profile. This includes clearing brush in wildfire-prone areas, ensuring proper drainage to prevent water damage, and keeping electrical and roofing systems up to date.
Work with a Trusted Insurance Advisor: Partnering with an experienced insurance agency is more important than ever. An advisor can help you shop the market, compare quotes from multiple carriers, and find personalized solutions. We have strong relationships with a wide range of carriers, including those who specialize in higher-risk properties, ensuring you have access to the best options available.
Consider Higher Deductibles: Increasing your deductible can lower your premium. However, it is crucial to ensure that you can comfortably cover the deductible amount in the event of a claim. We can help you analyze the financial trade-offs to make a decision that aligns with your budget.

Outlook for the California Insurance Market

The challenges in California’s commercial insurance market are not expected to disappear quickly. For commercial property, industry experts anticipate that rates will continue to rise as insurers catch up with past losses and adjust to ongoing catastrophic risks. The market is likely to remain “hard,” with stringent underwriting and less flexibility from carriers.

For commercial auto, tough conditions are also projected to persist into 2026. Experts predict continued rate increases as insurers contend with driver shortages, social inflation, and high repair costs.

However, there are signs of moderation. In the broader commercial property segment, rate increases began to slow in late 2024 and early 2025 for businesses with favorable risk profiles and limited exposure to natural disasters. This trend suggests that policyholders with a strong commitment to risk management will be best positioned to secure more favorable terms.

Your Partner in Protection

Navigating the complexities of the California insurance market requires expertise and a proactive approach. At Teague Insurance, we are committed to being your trusted partner. Our team provides the dedicated service and deep industry knowledge necessary to protect your business assets. We will work with you to understand your unique needs, identify potential risks, and tailor an insurance program that provides both security and value.

Previous Article Next Article